Friday, 12 February 2016

Didactic Accuracy vs Creative Expression and the Burden of Representing History on Screen

My aim is to explore the burden placed on historically-based narrative films to represent historical accurately and holistically instead of being allowed the freedom to use history for aesthetic expression and emotional responses from audiences. Films from the most recent five years will be used in the study to concentrate the focus with an examination of the confluence of reality and fantasy in these films. The way this assembly of ostensibly opposing forces affects the critical reaction to the films as potentially historical texts and/or pieces of entertainment will be key.

In this regard, the focus will be more on reaction from the film-critic intelligentsia and other filmmakers’ than general audiences. The dichotomy between real and created in these narratives points to a complementary issue worthy of exploration, where “serious” films tend to regard fantasy as something untrustworthy or dangerous, a tendency which seeps into film-critic culture where the “imagined” in historical fiction is seen as a threat to the “truth”. This trend demands exploration when film as a medium is marked by its essential unreality, and the transference of history to narrative requires invention.

It may be helpful to examine historical narrative films which, themselves, seem to regard their fantasy/created elements with embarrassment against narrative films which draw attention to their use artifice, whether for political or aesthetic reasons. In choosing the films for focus the question of “responsibility” of filmmakers in using certain historical incidences for “mere” fiction will be examined in hopes of examining two key issues: a) the fairness of these films being burdened with being “accurate” or “responsible”; and b) the possibility that placing those burdens on films intrinsically cripples the creative process resulting in art which is forced to sacrifice the aesthetical and cathartic for the didactical and ethical.

Prospective Primary Films: 
No (Larrain, 2012)
Lincoln (Spielberg, 2012)
Argo (Affleck, 2012)
Zero Dark Thirty (Bigelow, 2012)
Django Unchained (Tarantino, 2012)
Suffragette (Gavron, 2015)
12 Years A Slave (McQueen, 2013)
Tabu (Gomes, 2012)
Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close (Daldry, 2011)

No comments:

Post a Comment